Buy this domain.

NEJM Editors Urge High Court to Reject Defective Drug Lawsuit Shield | cialis online

NEJM Editors Urge High Court to Reject Defective Drug Lawsuit Shield

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Alarmed that the U.S. Supreme Court might hand drug makers a powerful lawsuit shield when it hears an important case this fall, editors at the New England Journal of Medicine (NEJM) have written an Amicus Brief arguing against such a ruling. On the other side, drug make Wyeth is trying to convince the High Court that Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval of a drug preempts the filing of defective drug product liability lawsuits in state courts.

Forty-seven state attorneys general have joined the NEJM in supporting Levine’s lawsuit. So have two former FDA commissioners – David Kessler, who served in the Clinton Administration, and Donald Kennedy who served in the Administration of George H.W. Bush.

Unfortunately, the deck appears to be stacked in favor of drug makers. The current Bush Administration is backing Wyeth, and the U.S. Solicitor General filed his own Amicus Brief favoring the drug maker back in June. In February, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of medical device makers in a similar case, Riegel vs. Medtronic, Inc. That case stemmed from a lawsuit filed by the family of a New York man who suffered severe medical complications when a Medtronic-made balloon catheter burst during a procedure to clear his arteries. The man’s family sued Medtronic, claiming his injuries were caused by the catheter’s negligent design, manufacture and labeling, despite the fact the device had won FDA approval.

Before the Supreme Court, Medtronic argued that the Medical Device Amendments of 1976 to the Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act that require FDA approval of medical devices preempt product liability lawsuits in state courts. Unfortunately for consumers, the Court agreed with the device maker. Now, many Court watchers say they have no reason to believe that the Justices will rule differently in Wyeth Vs. Levine.

This latest Supreme Court case, Wyeth vs. Levine, involves a Vermont woman who alleged she lost her arm from adverse events tied to Wyeth’s nausea and motion sickness drug Phenergan. Levine, who was awarded more than $6 million in her state court claim against Wyeth, said she was administered Phenergan at her local hospital emergency room. The product normally is administered intramuscularly, but hospital staff used a method called I.V. push of injecting the drug into her vein, which resulted in an inadvertent arterial injection. Inadvertent arterial injection of Phenergan is known to be dangerous. Levine, a guitar player, developed gangrene in her arm, which resulted in it being amputated.

Levine has contended that Phenergan’s labeling failed to adequately warn about the dangers of using the I.V. push method. In 2000, the same year Levine sustained her injury, Wyeth changed the label of Phenergan to warn that the drug should not be given by intra-arterial injection because of the risk of gangrene.

Wyeth claims that the FDA had weighed the risks and benefits of Phenergan in approving the drug’s prescribing literature, or label, as a guide for doctors. The FDA was aware of risks associated with injecting some forms of Phenergan, but did not require the label to specifically warn about the technique used with Levine. Wyeth claims that the FDA’s judgment in such matters cannot be overruled by a state court.

The authors of the NEJM do a pretty good job of picking apart the drug industry’s arguments for preemption. They write that the “FDA alone simply lacks the ability to serve as the sole guarantor of drug safety.’’ Without the discoveries found by plaintiff’s lawyers during the course of defective drug lawsuits, “the FDA would be stripped of an essential source of information that the agency has consistently relied on when making its regulatory decisions, and the American public would be deprived of a vital deterrent against pharmaceutical company misconduct.’’The authors point to several instances were FDA oversight was not able to keep dangerous drugs – such as Vioxx, Trasylol, fen-phen and Redux – off the market. In many cases, evidence that drug makers withheld or manipulated vital safety information about these drugs was only discovered once lawsuits were underway.

The NEJM Amicus Brief also takes issue with the pharmaceutical industry’s arguments too many drug warnings hurt consumers. According to the industry’s line of thinking, such “over-warnings” confuse patients and doctors, and cause people to stop taking drugs that could benefit them. They also make the claim that the FDA could punish drug companies for adding unnecessary warnings to medications.

But as the NEJM editors point out, the agency has never once in its history punished a drug maker for furnishing consumers with too many warnings. Also, the NEJM Amicus Brief argues that pharmaceutical companies have not provided any empirical evidence to support their assertions that consumers will top using beneficial medications because of too many warnings.

The NEJM editors also contradict claims that lawsuits are causing the drug industry serious economic harm. In the brief they write that “The prescription drug industry earns global revenues of more than $700 billion per year, an increase of $178 billion over the last five years.” While, “As of 2004, Americans were responsible for $248 billion in pharmaceutical sales, accounting for nearly 45 percent of all revenue worldwide. Despite representations of a so-called explosion of stifling litigation, the pharmaceutical market has grown, not shrunk.”

« »

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.




Defective Johnson & Johnson Depuy ASR Hip Implants

The Johnson & Johnson Depuy ASR Hip Implant is suppose to last 15 years, but can fail in only a few years after surgery. Victims with faulty hip implants endure excruciating pain, pain in the groin, death of tissue in the hip joint and loss of surrounding bone. GET ALL THE FACTS NOW! CLICK HERE!

CAT Scans Radiation Exposure

If you had a CT or CAT scan and now have a band of missing hair, skin reddening or any other problems possibly related to a radiation overdose, you may have been exposed to much radiation due to incorrect settings on these machines. CONTACT US TODAY!

Water Contamination From Fracking

Hydraulic Fracturing of Fracking a way to extract natural gas from shale is contaminating water supplies across the country. Get the facts to keep your drinking water safe for your family.

Overexposure to PCBs

Many people unknowingly have been exposed to high levels of PCBs. Recently 3 schools in NY City were found to have dangerous levels of PCBs throughout. Many workers for Monsanto, General Electric, and Westinghouse were exposed to high levels of PCBs. PCBs are a dangerous toxic substance that doesn't break down easily and can cause chloracne, bleeding and neurological disorders, liver damage, spontaneous abortions, malformed babies, cancer, and death. GET THE FACTS!
Overexposure to

Great Photography

Tallis Photo, the number one photographer for great corporate, wedding, and special occasion photos. CONTACT US TODAY!

Poligrip Lawsuit

Super Poligrip or Fixodent May Cause Nerve Damage. 800-LAW-INFO

Personal Injury Lawyer Nassau County

If you or someone you love was injured CONTACT US TODAY!

Nursing Home Blog

When a loved one is abused at a nursing home, it is time to take action. STOP nursing home abuse!

Car Accident Lawyer Nassau County

If you or someone you love was injured in an auto accident CONTACT US TODAY!

Suffolk County Auto Accident Lawyer

If you or someone you love was injured in an auto accident in Suffolk County, NY CONTACT US TODAY!

Don't Be Denied Veterans Benefits

If you or someone you love was denied veterans benefits CONTACT US TODAY!

Oil Rig Spills Lawyer

Oil Rig Spills harm the environment and cause heavy losses to coastal game and fishing industries, as well as a loss of waterway usage, resulting in a loss of income to individuals and businesses, and a loss of beach front usage. Don't let a spill cause you harm, CONTACT US TODAY!

Whistle Blower

Stand up and say what you think is right. See something, say something.