cialis online

Denver Three” Cases Test Limits of Free Speech

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

On March 21, 2005, a little more than two years ago, three Colorado residents–Leslie Weise, Alex Young, and Karen Bauer were forcibly ejected from a public presidential forum about Social Security privatization. Although the taxpayer-funded meeting was open to the public and all three possessed tickets for the event, local organizers, at the behest of White House staffers, decided to remove the three patrons because they arrived in a car with a bumper sticker reading, “No More Blood for Oil.” It was determined that the three “dissenters” could be seen as a potential threat to disrupt the meeting, even though they had not acted in a suspicious, disruptive, or threatening way.

Two separate civil lawsuits have been filed by the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) on behalf of two members of the “Denver Three,” as the ejected Denver residents have become known. The first suit, filed in November of 2005, named local organizers of the event, Jay Bob Klinkerman and Michael Casper, as defendants in the case (Weise v. Casper), claiming that the defendants’ actions “violated plaintiffs’ First and Fourth Amendment rights” for denial of free speech and unlawful search and seizure. The plaintiffs filed a second complaint last month, also in the U.S. District Court for Colorado, naming as defendants Greg Jenkins and other Washington-based White House staffers, who have been accused of orchestrating the ejection of the Denver Three and of “establishing and enforcing a policy to eject persons” from public meetings “on the basis of their viewpoint.” Klinkerman and Casper have also claimed that they were merely acting under orders of the White House staff members who helped organize the event.

In a motion filed with the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last week, attorneys for Casper and Klinkerman (who, incidentally, was the head of the Colorado Young Republicans organization at the time of the incident) declared, “The president may constitutionally make viewpoint-based exclusionary determinations in conveying his own message. So in following the instructions of the White House and carrying out its viewpoint-based exclusions, Casper and Klinkerman did not violate any of plaintiffs’ constitutional rights.” Defense attorneys originally sought to have the case dismissed in lower court by saying that Casper and Klinkerman had the right to qualified governmental immunity, but the district court rejected that motion.

Evidence clearly suggests that the Denver brouhaha was not an isolated incident. Various news reports have detailed similar incidents across the country in which citizens with “dissenting” viewpoints were denied admission to public, taxpayer-funded presidential events. When the original suit was filed in November of 2005, Weise said at the time, “What was supposed to be an historic opportunity for us to attend an event with a sitting president quickly turned into a humiliating and frightening experience. We had every right to attend the president’s event, and have decided to fight back to protect the Constitutional rights of all Americans.”

Added ACLU Senior Staff Attorney Chris Hansen, the case’s lead counsel, “The government should not be in the business of silencing Americans who are perceived to be critical of certain policy decisions. The president should be willing to be in the same room with people who might disagree with him, especially at a public, taxpayer-funded town hall.”

However, attorneys for Klinkerman and Casper are taking the exact opposite approach by claiming that their clients had every right to dismiss patrons “because they posed a threat of being disruptive.” Suffice to say, supporters of free speech in the United States are keeping a close eye on the proceedings of the Denver Three cases.

« »

Comments are closed.

NEWS CATEGORIES

GOVERNMENT NOTICES

ARCHIVES


Defective Johnson & Johnson Depuy ASR Hip Implants

The Johnson & Johnson Depuy ASR Hip Implant is suppose to last 15 years, but can fail in only a few years after surgery. Victims with faulty hip implants endure excruciating pain, pain in the groin, death of tissue in the hip joint and loss of surrounding bone. GET ALL THE FACTS NOW! CLICK HERE!
defective-hip-replacement.com

CAT Scans Radiation Exposure

If you had a CT or CAT scan and now have a band of missing hair, skin reddening or any other problems possibly related to a radiation overdose, you may have been exposed to much radiation due to incorrect settings on these machines. CONTACT US TODAY!
CAT-Scans-Radiation-Exposure.com

Water Contamination From Fracking

Hydraulic Fracturing of Fracking a way to extract natural gas from shale is contaminating water supplies across the country. Get the facts to keep your drinking water safe for your family.
WaterContaminationFrom Fracking.com

Overexposure to PCBs

Many people unknowingly have been exposed to high levels of PCBs. Recently 3 schools in NY City were found to have dangerous levels of PCBs throughout. Many workers for Monsanto, General Electric, and Westinghouse were exposed to high levels of PCBs. PCBs are a dangerous toxic substance that doesn't break down easily and can cause chloracne, bleeding and neurological disorders, liver damage, spontaneous abortions, malformed babies, cancer, and death. GET THE FACTS!
Overexposure to PCBs.com

Great Photography

Tallis Photo, the number one photographer for great corporate, wedding, and special occasion photos. CONTACT US TODAY!
TallisPhoto.com

Poligrip Lawsuit

Super Poligrip or Fixodent May Cause Nerve Damage. 800-LAW-INFO
Poligrip-Lawsuit.com

Personal Injury Lawyer Nassau County

If you or someone you love was injured CONTACT US TODAY!
Nassau-Personal-Injury-Lawyer-Online.com

Nursing Home Blog

When a loved one is abused at a nursing home, it is time to take action. STOP nursing home abuse!
nursing-home-blog.com

Car Accident Lawyer Nassau County

If you or someone you love was injured in an auto accident CONTACT US TODAY!
www.nassau-car-accident-lawyer-online.com

Suffolk County Auto Accident Lawyer

If you or someone you love was injured in an auto accident in Suffolk County, NY CONTACT US TODAY!
www.suffolk-car-accident-lawyer-online.com

Don't Be Denied Veterans Benefits

If you or someone you love was denied veterans benefits CONTACT US TODAY!
www.veterans-benefits-denial.com

Oil Rig Spills Lawyer

Oil Rig Spills harm the environment and cause heavy losses to coastal game and fishing industries, as well as a loss of waterway usage, resulting in a loss of income to individuals and businesses, and a loss of beach front usage. Don't let a spill cause you harm, CONTACT US TODAY!
www.oil-rig-spills.com

Whistle Blower

Stand up and say what you think is right. See something, say something.
whistlebloweradvisor.com